Then who was X

From Encyclopedia Dramatica

"THEN WHO WAS X" is a meme originating on 4chan's /x/ board. Most commonly, 'X' is 'Phone,' due to the original story. Newfags will frequently post "THEN WHO WAS X" if there is absolutely ANY vagueness in creepypasta. Go ahead, go to /x/ and post a vague story. But be prepared for floods of "THEN WHO WAS" spam, because it will happen.

Contents 1 The original creepypasta 2 Translated from moonspeak to English 3 Translated from English to Ebonics 4 Variations 5 The Boring Answer 6 The Fixed Version 7 People just don't get it 8 Pix or it didn't happen you say?

[edit] The original creepypasta

“	So ur with ur honey and yur making out wen the phone rigns. U anser it n the vioce is "wut r u doing wit my daughter?" U tell ur girl n she say "my dad is ded". THEN WHO WAS PHONE?	„

[edit] Translated from moonspeak to English

“	You are making out with your girlfriend when suddenly the phone rings. You pick up and ask, "Hello?" The voice on the other end says "WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING WITH MY DAUGHTER??" Just then, your girlfriend says her father's been dead for three years. THEN WHO WAS THAT CHARMING GENTLEMAN ON THE PHONE?	„

[edit] Translated from English to Ebonics

“	You makin' out wit yo bitch when the fone rings. You say "Wassup" and da nigga on the other end say "Nigga, what the fuck you doin' wit my daughter!?" Then yo bitch say "I don't know my daddy." THEN WHO THE FUCK WAS ON DA FONE?	„

[edit] Variations

There aren't many kinds of the original story, although there must be over nine thousand kinds of BUT WHO WAS-. Common examples include "Then who was internet" and "Then who was post."

[edit] The Boring Answer

Her mom or she was lying, duh.

[edit] The Fixed Version

“	You are making out with your girlfriend when suddenly the phone rings. You pick up and say, "Hello" The voice on the other end starts QQing "WHAT THE FUCKING HELL ARE YOU DOING WITH MY DAUGHTER??" Your girlfriend overhears the yelling. She says her father's been dead for three years and her mom was an hero. THEN WHO WAS PHONE?	„

[edit] People just don't get it

• Creepypasta.com WHO WAS PHONE Comment Section - meme drama?

You are making out with your girlfriend when suddenly the phone rings. You pick up and say, "Hello" The voice on the other end starts QQing "WHAT THE FUCKING HELL ARE YOU DOING WITH MY DAUGHTER??" Your girlfriend overhears the yelling. She says her father's been dead for three years and her mom was an hero. THEN WHO WAS PHONE?

[edit] Pix or it didn't happen you say?

A challenger appears?	Now in ASCII.	In comic strip form as well.	In manga form as well
Ye olde creepypasta

	Then who was X is part of	Classic	Solid	Chanspeak
	a series on Memes	Fleeting	Failed	Not a Meme
	Click one of the six categories to expand that category. Time-Tested Classics 4chan Stencils • A Cat Is Fine Too • A winner is you • An Hero • Baby fuck • Barrel roll • Bayeux Tapestry • Bel-Air • Bitches Don't Know • Bix Nood • Brian Peppers • Bridget • Bunny Pancake • Buy A Dog • Candlejack • Catnarok • Caturday • Ceiling Cat • Centipede filled vagina • Chin-chan • Chuck Norris • Cockmongler • Copypasta • Creepypasta • Delicious Cake • Demotivators • Desu • Diabeetus • Divide By Zero • DO IT FAGGOT • DO NOT WANT • Duckroll • Epic Fail Guy • Epic Threads • FGSFDS • F40PH • Gaijin 4Koma • George Zimmer • Goodnight Sweet Prince • HA! HA! Guy • HAHAHA DISREGARD THAT, I SUCK COCKS • Happycat • Happy Negro • How Do I Shot Web? • I Am In Your Base Killing Your D00ds • I Came • I Has A Shuvel • IMMA CHARGIN MAH LAZER • INTERNET HATE MACHINE • I See What You Did There • Over 9000 • ITTY BITTY BABY ITTY BITTY BOAT • JESUS CHRIST IT'S A LION GET IN THE CAR! • LOL WUT • Longcat • Massimo D'Alema • Milhouse is not a meme • Moar • Mudkips • Nevada-tan • O RLY • Pedobear • ???? • Pool's Closed • Profit • Raptor Jesus • Rickroll • The Sandwich Chef • This Looks Shopped • Waha • WRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY • Yaranaika • ZA WARUDO Ordinary Memes 404 Girl • Awesome • BIKECAT • Blockatiel • Borscht • Broccoli Dog • Cactuar • Card Crusher • Chris Hansen • Dicks everywhere • DOUBLE NIGGER • Doug • DSFARGEG • Garfield • ENGLISH MOTHERFUCKER • Frosted Butts • Gaijin 4Koma • Gentlemen • Happy Snake • House • Hypnotoad • I am Legend • I GOT NORTON! • I'd Hit It • INVISIBLE... • IS IT CAN BE HUGS TIEM NOW PLEES? • Is This Battletoads • It's a Trap! • Jam It In • John Locke • KILL IT WITH FIRE • Law 4 Kids • lolicatgirls.swf • Machine Code • Man The Harpoons • Mario Drawings • Milk Bags • MSPaint Relationship Thread • Nanomachines • Not This Shit Again • OM NOM NOM NOM • Party Hard • PLEASE RESPOND • Pretty cool guy • Push Butan • Put Shoe On Head • Rape Clock • Shitting Dick Nipples • Slowpoke • Speedycat • Spengbab • Steel Hearts • Teh Rei • That Fucking Cat • delayclose.jpg • TONIGHT WE DINE IN HELL • USB Cable • Vespene gas • Weegee • What is Love? • Wrong Location Nigger • X? In My Y? • YOU ARE DOING IT WRONG • Zippocat Jargon and Textual Memes Bring Back Snacks • But who was x • Bump • Clippit • Combofag • Drawhore • Fixed • Fukken saved • Grey Area • HA HA HA, OH WOW • I don't think you have an X. Enjoy your Y. • in before X • lurk moar • Never forget • NO U • Nobody Cares • Oh exploitable • Pic Unrelated • Posting in an epic thread • Relevant to my interests • Rules Of The Internet • Sauce • Stick It In Her Pooper • Stop posting • Verbose Thread • Weeaboo • WHARRGARBL • Where is your X now? • X is not your personal army • X Y is X 15 Minutes of Fame 360 kid • 4chan Battlecards • 4chan Gaming • 4chan Gold Account • Apathy Dog • Approval Guy • Audio • Beat A Rod • Because of Parkinson's • Child Abduction • BRB, CHURCH • brb, compromised • brb, soup • Brinks Home Security • Dental Plan • Dynamic Entry • Extreme Advertising • Feels good man • Fishing Cat • Flea Market Montgomery • #fortune • Ffruustration • Gary Oak • Godhand Edit • Goofy Time • Grin Reaper • Guess The Meme • Hi-tech military software • Holy Grail • I DIDN'T EAT THAT FUCKIN SANDWICH OR THE TOILET THING EITHER! • I Has A Bucket • I need a price check ... • I TOUCHED HIS PENIS!! OMG • Josef Fritzl • JxcelDolghmQ • Time for a Dicking • Chocolate Rain • Large Hadron Collider • Leave Bond to me • LINK MAH BOIIIII • LOLCHAIR • Mavica Sprite • Michael Phelps • Mordor • Nod Flenders • Octocat • Oh No You Didn't • Operation Falcon Punch • Operation LIONCASH • Power Wrist • ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWAH • SFW Porn • Shamwow • Steve Irwin • Stingray • SUP DAWG • Swirl Face • Switch police on • Tapestry Dog • Tyrannosaurus Reich • Uninformed Lisa • VTEC Just Kicked In Yo • What is a man? • Why So Exploitable? • Why So Serious? • Woll Smoth • Zach Braff Quotes Close But No Cigar Apples Bear • Asianface • Big Dog • Bill • CAPS EAGLE • COMBO BREAKER • Cool your jets • Dick Butt • Drama Prairie Dog • FUCK YEAH SEAKING • Furseiseki • The Fury • Gaston • GET • Get into the Loop • Hai guy • I AM BEOWULF! • I don't roll that way • Jack Spicer • L-L-LUNAJACK! • Living On A Prayer • Matt Gunderman • Navid • Nyoro~n • Objection! • oh shit i'm sorry i meant • Redtube Roulette • Rita • SHIT IT OFF • Shortcat • Skittle Nigger • Smoking Crab • Staredog • So cash • TAP LADEDANS FISTON! • THE BEST • UNITINU • WHEN I WAS • You Laugh, You Lose • YOU'RE A BIRD! No. Milhouse